Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

Issue with MIFARE Ultralight EV1 Emulation: Missing Data in Pages 18 and 19 #238

Open
Septimus4 opened this issue Nov 12, 2024 · 13 comments
Open

Issue with MIFARE Ultralight EV1 Emulation: Missing Data in Pages 18 and 19 #238

Septimus4 opened this issue Nov 12, 2024 · 13 comments

Comments

@Septimus4
Copy link

Septimus4 commented Nov 12, 2024 •
edited
Loading

Describe the bug
When attempting to emulate a MIFARE Ultralight EV1 48-byte tag, the ChameleonUltra is missing data on pages 18 and 19. One of these pages contains the tag's password, which seems necessary for authentication. Emulating this tag with the ChameleonUltra fails to unlock the door, suggesting missing or incorrect data.

To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Use Proxmark to read the MIFARE Ultralight EV1 48-byte tag with the following command: 
    [usb] pm3 --> hf mfu dump -k 8D322569 --ns
  2. Attempt to read the same tag using the ChameleonUltra: 
    [USB] chameleon --> hf mfu dump -k 8D322569
  3. Compare the Proxmark and ChameleonUltra outputs. Notably, pages 18 and 19 on the Chameleon are populated with 00000000 instead of the expected values (8D322569 in page 18 and EC2F0000 in page 19).

Expected behavior
The ChameleonUltra should accurately replicate all data pages of the MIFARE Ultralight tag, including pages 18 and 19, to enable successful emulation and authentication.

Screenshots
Proxmark Output:

[usb] pm3 --> hf mfu dump -k 8D322569 --ns
[+] TYPE: MIFARE Ultralight EV1 48bytes (MF0UL1101)
[+] Reading tag memory...

[=] MFU dump file information
[=] -------------------------------------------------------------
[=] Version..... 00 04 03 01 01 00 0B 03
[=] TBD 0....... 00 00
[=] TBD 1....... 00
[=] Signature... 31 C9 18 7A A2 2F F4 F1 34 53 18 1D 7A BB 75 9B
[=]              5B 24 FC DC E9 01 84 A3 66 C4 28 26 51 61 5C F4
[=] Counter 0... 00 00 00
[=] Tearing 0... BD
[=] Counter 1... 00 00 00
[=] Tearing 1... BD
[=] Counter 2... 00 00 00
[=] Tearing 2... BD
[=] Max data page... 19 ( 80 bytes )
[=] Header size..... 56 bytes

[=] -------------------------------------------------------------
[=] block#   | data        |lck| ascii
[=] ---------+-------------+---+------
[=]   0/0x00 | 04 36 FA 40 |   | .6.@
[=]   1/0x01 | D2 52 1B 90 |   | .R..
[=]   2/0x02 | 0B 48 08 00 |   | .H..
[=]   3/0x03 | 9A 02 56 20 | 1 | ..V
[=]   4/0x04 | 19 6F 81 52 | 0 | .o.R
[=]   5/0x05 | 11 0B 73 48 | 0 | ..sH
[=]   6/0x06 | B6 76 E4 9B | 0 | .v..
[=]   7/0x07 | D2 2A 9F 61 | 0 | .*.a
[=]   8/0x08 | A8 88 E4 3A | 0 | ...:
[=]   9/0x09 | 5A 82 24 41 | 0 | Z.$A
[=]  10/0x0A | 00 00 00 00 | 0 | ....
[=]  11/0x0B | 00 00 00 00 | 0 | ....
[=]  12/0x0C | 00 00 00 00 | 0 | ....
[=]  13/0x0D | 00 00 00 00 | 0 | ....
[=]  14/0x0E | 00 00 00 00 | 0 | ....
[=]  15/0x0F | 00 00 00 00 | 0 | ....
[=]  16/0x10 | 00 00 00 10 | 0 | ....
[=]  17/0x11 | 80 05 00 00 | 0 | ....
[=]  18/0x12 | 8D 32 25 69 | 0 | .2%i
[=]  19/0x13 | EC 2F 00 00 | 0 | ./..
[=] ---------------------------------

ChameleonUltra Output:

[USB] chameleon --> hf mfu dump -k 8D322569
 - Detected tag type as Mifare Ultralight EV1 48b.
 - PACK: ec2f
 - Page  0: 0436fa40
 - Page  1: d2521b90
 - Page  2: 0b480800
 - Page  3: 9a025620
 - Page  4: 196f8152
 - Page  5: 110b7348
 - Page  6: b676e49b
 - Page  7: d22a9f61
 - Page  8: a888e43a
 - Page  9: 5a822441
 - Page 10: 00000000
 - Page 11: 00000000
 - Page 12: 00000000
 - Page 13: 00000000
 - Page 14: 00000000
 - Page 15: 00000000
 - Page 16: 00000010
 - Page 17: 80050000
 - Page 18: 00000000
 - Page 19: 00000000

Host (please complete the following information):

  • OS and version: Ubuntu 24.04.1 LTS
  • ChameleonUltra CLI hardware version: 
    [USB] chameleon --> hw version
- Chameleon Ultra, Version: v2.0 (v2.0.0-203-g8a797b8)

Additional context
I am unsure if there’s an additional configuration step required or if this is a firmware issue. Any insights on how to address missing data for pages 18 and 19 would be appreciated. Thank you!
@Septimus4
Copy link
Author

Septimus4 commented Nov 12, 2024 •
edited
Loading

I have a second issue but since it could be related I will add it here, and if it is not I will move it to a new one.

Describe the bug
When attempting to use dumps from Proxmark as emulation data for the ChameleonUltra, I receive errors indicating that the dump file is too large for the available slot. I tried importing both .bin and .json formats, but both returned the same error message.

Is there a way to use proxmark dumps directly ?

To Reproduce
Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Create a MIFARE Ultralight EV1 48-byte dump with Proxmark.
  2. Attempt to load the Proxmark dump into the ChameleonUltra with the following commands: 
    [USB] chameleon --> hf mfu eload -f hf-mfu-0436FAD2521B90-dump.bin
Dump file is too large for the current slot (expected 80 bytes).
    And similarly: 
    [USB] chameleon --> hf mfu eload -f hf-mfu-0436FAD2521B90-dump.json
Dump file is too large for the current slot (expected 80 bytes).

Expected behavior
The ChameleonUltra should accept the full Proxmark dump.

Hex Dumps for Reference:

Proxmark .bin Dump:

❯ hexdump -C hf-mfu-0436FAD2521B90-dump.bin
00000000  00 04 03 01 01 00 0b 03  00 00 00 13 31 c9 18 7a  |............1..z|
00000010  a2 2f f4 f1 34 53 18 1d  7a bb 75 9b 5b 24 fc dc  |./..4S..z.u.[$..|
00000020  e9 01 84 a3 66 c4 28 26  51 61 5c f4 00 00 00 bd  |....f.(&Qa\.....|
00000030  00 00 00 bd 00 00 00 bd  04 36 fa 40 d2 52 1b 90  |[email protected]..|
00000040  0b 48 08 00 9a 02 56 20  19 6f 81 52 11 0b 73 48  |.H....V .o.R..sH|
00000050  b6 76 e4 9b d2 2a 9f 61  a8 88 e4 3a 5a 82 24 41  |.v...*.a...:Z.$A|
00000060  00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00  00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00  |................|
00000070  00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00  00 00 00 10 80 05 00 00  |................|
00000080  8d 32 25 69 ec 2f 00 00                           |.2%i./..|
00000088

Chameleon Dump:

❯ hexdump -C chameleon-dump.bin
00000000  04 36 fa 40 d2 52 1b 90  0b 48 08 00 9a 02 56 20  |[email protected] |
00000010  19 6f 81 52 11 0b 73 48  b6 76 e4 9b d2 2a 9f 61  |.o.R..sH.v...*.a|
00000020  a8 88 e4 3a 5a 82 24 41  00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00  |...:Z.$A........|
00000030  00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00  00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00  |................|
00000040  00 00 00 10 80 05 00 00  00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00  |................|
00000050

@GameTec-live
Copy link
Contributor

is the slot configured as a 4k or 1k?

@Septimus4
Copy link
Author

I am not sure to understand, since it's a Ultralight Ev1 I used the those commands:
hw slot type -s 3 -t MF0UL11
hw slot init -s 3 -t MF0UL11

@GameTec-live
Copy link
Contributor

Try setting the slot type to a 4k card and then loading the dump, should work too

@Septimus4
Copy link
Author

After further testing, here’s an update:

  1. I successfully wrote to an MF0UL21 tag, which provided more storage space. However, this did not unlock the door, and I’m not comfortable with this approach overall.

  2. I then attempted to convert my Proxmark MIFARE Ultralight dump to the ChameleonUltra format. My understanding is that I should isolate only the card data blocks from the Proxmark dump and arrange them in a format the Chameleon will accept. This conversion involves extracting only the raw data from Proxmark’s blocks section, excluding any other metadata.

Here's a comparison of the hexdumps for reference:

❯ hexdump -C hf-mfu-0436FAD2521B90-handcrafted-chameleon.bin
00000000  04 36 fa 40 d2 52 1b 90  0b 48 08 00 9a 02 56 20  |[email protected] |
00000010  19 6f 81 52 11 0b 73 48  b6 76 e4 9b d2 2a 9f 61  |.o.R..sH.v...*.a|
00000020  a8 88 e4 3a 5a 82 24 41  00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00  |...:Z.$A........|
00000030  00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00  00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00  |................|
00000040  00 00 00 10 80 05 00 00  8d 32 25 69 ec 2f 00 00  |.........2%i./..|
00000050

After preparing the file in this manner, I loaded it into the Chameleon without any errors or warnings using the following commands:

[USB] chameleon --> hw slot type -s 3 -t MF0UL11
 - Set slot 3 tag type success.
[USB] chameleon --> hw slot init -s 3 -t MF0UL11
 - Set slot tag data init success.
[USB] chameleon --> hf mfu eload -f hf-mfu-0436FAD2521B90-handcrafted-chameleon.bin
 - Ok
...

Though I had to set up the econfig values manually (which is quite tedious), the emulation finally worked, and the Chameleon successfully unlocked the door.

Key takeaways and issues identified:

  1. Potential bug in the dump command for MIFARE Ultralight EV1 tags with password protection, unless I’m missing something.
  2. Incompatibility between Proxmark and Chameleon dump formats.
  3. Manual econfig setup for each use is cumbersome.

@GameTec-live, could you advise if the roadmap and documentation are up-to-date?

I’m open to contributing by exploring the possibility of adding Proxmark dump import support for the Chameleon. This could also automate econfig population from the imported dump. I could also investigate the incomplete block dump issue, though I’m relatively new to NFC/RFID and haven't worked on embedded systems in a long time, so I can’t guarantee significant contributions yet.

@GameTec-live
Copy link
Contributor

Well, first off, sorry, i totally missed that your talking about ultralight (ig i shouldnt respond to issues on my phone at 6am lmao).
Thanks for all of that info. Yes, the CU and pm3 format are incompatible. The CLI in general is quite barebones. (may i recommend ChameleonUltraGUI? XD)
The roadmap and docs should mostly be up to date and correct? So if you want to do some development, feel free to go ahead, especially as stuff like PM3 imports would be client side and thats just pretty easy to deal with python.

@Septimus4
Copy link
Author

No worries thank you for your help and informations.
I did try to use the Gui first but I could not dump the tag, and when trying to import the dump from proxmark it seemed to only allow me to select mifare classic types.
Since there was multiple underlying issues I should probably try again now that I have a valid dump to import.

@GameTec-live
Copy link
Contributor

in the gui imports are still missing mfu support, didnt have the time yet.
You should be able to read it though?

@Septimus4
Copy link
Author

I could read the tag uid, but not dump the content since it's password protected.
To dump I would need to provide the password
Or sniff the reader, and I think both are not supported

@GameTec-live
Copy link
Contributor

the cu doesnt support sniffing, yep
But when reading you can provide a key / password

@198sashko1
Copy link

198sashko1 commented Nov 28, 2024 •
edited
Loading

Добрый вечер. Можно добавить пароль вручную. Но где его взять? Как его достать из считывателя? Good evening. You can add a password manually. But where can I get it? How do I get it out of the reader?

@GameTec-live
Copy link
Contributor

@198sashko1 In English please

@198sashko1
Copy link

198sashko1 commented Nov 28, 2024 •
edited
Loading

Good evening. You can add a password manually. But where can I get it? How do I get it out of the reader?

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests
3 participants
@Septimus4 @GameTec-live @198sashko1