diff --git a/Metallicity_Stack_Commons/valid_table.py b/Metallicity_Stack_Commons/valid_table.py
index 9efea12..12a61bf 100644
--- a/Metallicity_Stack_Commons/valid_table.py
+++ b/Metallicity_Stack_Commons/valid_table.py
@@ -3,10 +3,12 @@
 from astropy.io import ascii as asc
 from astropy.table import Table, Column
 
-from .column_names import filename_dict, valid_table_names0  # , bin_names0, remove_from_list
+from .column_names import filename_dict, valid_table_names0
 
 
-def make_validation_table(fitspath: str):
+def make_validation_table(fitspath: str, vmin_4363SN=3, vmin_5007SN=100,
+                          vmax_4363sig=1.6, rlmin_4363SN=3,
+                          rlmax_4363sig=1.6, rlmin_5007SN=100):
     """
     This function creates a validation table for a given binning set.
     The validation table contains a OIII4363 detection column where 1.0
@@ -20,6 +22,12 @@ def make_validation_table(fitspath: str):
 
     :param fitspath: Full file path where the input file is and where the
                      output file will be placed.
+    :param vmin_4363SN: int. minimum OIII4363 S/N for valid detection
+    :param vmin_5007SN: int. minimum OIII5007 S/N for valid detection
+    :param vmax_4363sig: int. maximum OIII4363 sigma for valid detection
+    :param rlmin_4363SN: int. minimum OIII4363 S/N for robust limit
+    :param rlmax_4363sig: int. maximum OIII4363 sigma for robust limit
+    :param rlmin_5007SN: int. minimum OIII5007 S/N for robust limit
 
     Outputs:
       fitspath + 'bin_validation.tbl'
@@ -45,12 +53,17 @@ def make_validation_table(fitspath: str):
     OIII4363 = np.zeros(len(bin_ID))
     up_limit = (Hgamma/Hgamma_SN) * 3
 
-    valid_stacks_idx = np.where((O_4363_SN >= 3) & (O_5007_SN > 100) & (O_4363_sigma < 1.6))[0] 
-    reliable_5007_stacks = np.where((O_4363_SN < 3) & (O_5007_SN > 100))[0]
-    wide_lines_valid = np.where((O_4363_SN >= 3) & (O_5007_SN > 100) & (O_4363_sigma >= 1.6))[0]
-    detection[valid_stacks_idx] = 1
+    valid_stacks_idx = np.where((O_4363_SN >= vmin_4363SN) &
+                                (O_5007_SN > vmin_5007SN) &
+                                (O_4363_sigma < vmax_4363sig))[0]
+    reliable_5007_stacks = np.where((O_4363_sigma < rlmax_4363sig) &
+                                    (O_5007_SN > rlmin_5007SN))[0]
+    wide_line_valid = np.where((O_4363_SN >= rlmin_4363SN) &
+                               (O_5007_SN > rlmin_5007SN) &
+                               (O_4363_sigma >= rlmax_4363sig))[0]
     detection[reliable_5007_stacks] = 0.5
-    detection[wide_lines_valid] = 0.5
+    detection[wide_line_valid] = 0.5
+    detection[valid_stacks_idx] = 1
     print(detection)
 
     for ii in range(len(OIII4363)):
@@ -62,22 +75,9 @@ def make_validation_table(fitspath: str):
             OIII4363[ii] = up_limit[ii]
 
     ver_tab = fitspath + filename_dict['bin_valid']
-    tab1 = Table([bin_ID, N_stack, detection, OIII4363, O_4363_SN], names=valid_table_names0)
+    tab1 = Table([bin_ID, N_stack, detection, OIII4363, O_4363_SN],
+                 names=valid_table_names0)
     asc.write(tab1, ver_tab, format='fixed_width_two_line')
-    '''
-    # Write revised file for human editing
-    ver_tab_revised = fitspath + filename_dict['bin_valid_rev']
-    if not exists(ver_tab_revised):
-        asc.write(tab1, ver_tab_revised, format='fixed_width_two_line')
-        print("   ")
-        print("URGENT!!! HUMAN EDITING OF FILE NEEDED : "+ver_tab_revised)
-        print("   ")
-    else:
-        print("   ")
-        print("ERROR!!! FILE EXISTS!!!  WILL NOT OVERWRITE !!!")
-        print("ERROR!!! PLEASE RENAME/DELETE FILE TO REGENERATE !!!")
-        print("   ")
-    '''
 
 
 def compare_to_by_eye(fitspath: str, dataset: str):
@@ -130,14 +130,14 @@ def compare_to_by_eye(fitspath: str, dataset: str):
             np.where(
                 (ID == 0) | (ID == 1) | (ID == 2) | (ID == 7) | (ID == 9) |
                 (ID == 10) | (ID == 11) | (ID == 13))[0]
-    if dataset == 'n_Bins':
+    # make_validation_table will now produce correct detection values
+    '''if dataset == 'n_Bins':
         det_4363 = np.where(
             (ID == 10) | (ID == 14) | (ID == 15) | (ID == 20) |
             (ID == 23) | (ID == 26))[0]
         rlimit = \
-            np.where(
-                (ID == 5) | (ID == 7) | (ID == 8) | (ID == 11) | (ID == 13)
-                | (ID == 16) | (ID == 17) | (ID == 19) | (ID == 22))[0]
+            np.where((ID == 8) | (ID == 11) | (ID == 13)| (ID == 16)
+                      | (ID == 17) | (ID == 19) | (ID == 22))[0]'''
 
     # Caroline: Add you conditions here