Switch thumb not disabled when enclosed in a disabled <fieldset>

[ulken]

Problem

Switch thumb not disabled when enclosed in a disabled <fieldset>.

Demo

Cause

All form fields (<input>, <button> etc.) inside a <fieldset> are disabled. This results in the wrapping <button>, representing the track, being disabled. However, the <span> representing the thumb is not, as it's not considered a form field. Thus the Switch is still toggleable.

Workaround

Explicitly add disabled to <button>.

Solution

Not really sure what would be a clean solution of determining if enclosed in a (disabled) <fieldset>. Unfortunately the disabled property of the <button> is not set. Walking up the DOM is one way. Any other suggestions?

Anyway, I would assume the entire Switch to be disabled in this case.

[RobinMalfait]

Hey! Thank you for your bug report!
Much appreciated! 🙏

This is a very interesting issue. I see what is happening and I think there might be a good solution here. Long story short if you would press the label or the gray area you will notice that it doesn't work.

Apparently, something I didn't know, is that if you have an element like a button with an onClick in a disabled fieldset, then the onClick will not be fired. That's the reason why it works as expected when clicking on the label or the gray area. Because the underlying button is now disabled.

Wow, while I was investigating this, I came up with this example: https://codesandbox.io/s/angry-wing-k4lif?file=/src/App.js
Notice that you can't click the button text, but you can click the text that is inside the span inside the button.

I re-created this in vanillajs and there it works as expected... https://codesandbox.io/s/currying-cache-mtso0?file=/src/index.js

I believe that we found a React bug!

---

Seems to be reported before: facebook/react#7711

[RobinMalfait]

I commented on the open issue on the React repo. Hopefully we can figure something out.

In the mean time, one of the temporary fixes would be to add a disabled prop to your button as you mentioned. Another potential temporary fix could be something like this:

button:disabled * {
  pointer-events: none;
}

It's more like a global fix everywhere, and once that is fixed inside React you should be able to drop this.

If React will not fix it, then I'll think about a fix inside Headless UI itself!

[ulken]

I believe that we found a React bug!

---

Seems to be reported before: facebook/react#7711

Well, what do you know, huh? That's what you get for using synthetic events, aye? A re-implementation is tricky to get right...

Nice digging. Hope they finally address it. How much time will you give them before taking things in your own hands?

The only part I disagree on is:

> That's the reason why it works as expected when clicking on the label or the gray area.

I'd say the opposite. That's unexpected behavior.

Nevermind me. You're absolutely right.

[ulken]

Another potential temporary fix could be something like this:

button:disabled * {

  pointer-events: none;

}

This won't work with the label though, right?

... but that's already handled by the <fieldset>.

[RobinMalfait]

I'm going to try and implement a relatively easy fix inside Headless UI itself this Friday. I also saw that they answered on the React repo so maybe things will go quick enough. We'll see.

[ulken]

Sweet! I’ll make sure to try it out.

[ulken]

Hum, running npm i @headlessui/react@dev doesn't install a new version. Care to update?

[RobinMalfait]

@ulken Sorry about that, I didn't publish it back then. Can you retry?

[ulken]

No worries. Yes, it works now. Thanks!

[imclint21]

Any update about how to disabled a switch?