-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 2.4k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
MySQL, OrchardCore.ContentFields.Indexing.SQL, Specified key was too long; max key length is 3072 bytes #14338
Comments
Have you tried to upgrade to 1.6 then 1.7? |
The default MySql collation has changed, we already have to reduce the size of some indexes, from memory for See these comments OrchardCore/src/OrchardCore.Modules/OrchardCore.Alias/Migrations.cs Lines 25 to 33 in 9a76299
Just checking the Anyway would only work for fresh installations, so for now the column length of the related index tables need to be changed manually. |
I haven't.
Shouldn't be a problem.
Just to confirm, is this something you guys will fix and release in upcoming versions of Orchard Core? |
We spent some time trying to understand the issue during triage and we think we understand the issues completely. An index entry in MySQL can't contain more than 3072 bytes. With the current default utf8nb4 collation this accounts for 768 chars. This means that all the fields which make up an index entry can't go over that, but only in MySQL. MySQL has a custom syntax to define the prefix size of an index, meaning the amount of data to use for each field. For instance we can limit the In YesSql the columns names are injected as-is in the SQL Query: https://github.com/sebastienros/yessql/blob/c0771eb555c67bf419859016cb3563a3540fe7c7/src/YesSql.Core/Sql/BaseComandInterpreter.cs#L233 So if we change the current migration to something like this, this would work: SchemaBuilder.AlterIndexTable<AliasPartIndex>(table => table
.CreateIndex("IDX_AliasPartIndex_DocumentId",
"DocumentId",
"Alias(123)",
"ContentItemId",
"Published",
"Latest")
); ... as long as the sum of these constraints is less than 767 chars. (this doesn't work on binary formats, e.g. bools, numbers, ...) But this only works for MySql, so if we don't want to change YesSql we need to do an The other option is to use this syntax in all cases (any db provider) and have YesSql custom command interpreters exclude this part when it's not supported. |
Fix #14338 --------- Co-authored-by: yaricrolletservico <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Hisham Bin Ateya <[email protected]>
@sebastienros @jtkech:
(New logs pasted from Docker)
|
After a quick look there is at least one missing index that has not been reduced This one has been reduced
But not this one, the size of So DocumentId (2) + Text (766) + even if both booleans only take 1 char size = 769 chars. No luck, the max is 768 chars size => 768 * 4 = 3072 bytes ;)
Edited: Idem for this one
And this one
|
Is that mean we need a hot fix? |
Yes I think, maybe 1.7.2 ;) |
The feature needs to be enabled in functional tests as part of the fix. |
IMHO no need to rush during the release to avoid such issues |
@hieucd04 1.7.2 was released today. Please give that a try and let us know if you run into additional issues. Thank you |
@MikeAlhayek FYI, while testing |
Yes I saw the issue, are you using the OpenId feature? |
@jtkech I enabled the below OpenId features:
|
Can't repro by just enabling these 2 features but there is nothing to prune, but I can see the query well executed in the background task (I set the period to 1 minute for testing). I will copy paste this comment in the related issue |
* mkdocs-material 9.2.8 * Release 1.7 (OrchardCMS#14111) * Switch to 1.8.0-preview * Position the modal over the navbar (OrchardCMS#14270) * Add 1.8 release notes file. (OrchardCMS#14277) * jQuery 3.7.1 (OrchardCMS#14231) * Add @brutoledo as a contributor * Add @dannyd89 as a contributor * Typo SMS features * Update libphonenumber-csharp 8.13.20 (OrchardCMS#14287) * NLog.Web.AspNetCore 5.3.4 (OrchardCMS#14283) * leaflet 1.9.4 (OrchardCMS#14054) * bootstrap-select 1.14.0-beta3 (OrchardCMS#14282) * Fixes invalid cookie name (OrchardCMS#14280) * Add @ludovic-th as a contributor * Move Moq into tests libraries (OrchardCMS#14260) * Microsoft.Identity.Web 2.13.4 (OrchardCMS#14292) * BenchmarkDotNet 0.13.8 (OrchardCMS#14293) * mkdocs-material 9.3.0 * mkdocs-material 9.3.1 * Remove duplicate alert in settings (OrchardCMS#14299) * Make WorkflowType extension able (OrchardCMS#14275) * NET 6.0.22, 7.0.11 (OrchardCMS#14320) * Update OpenIddict 4.8.0 (OrchardCMS#14321) * Update Jint 3.0.0-beta-2051 (OrchardCMS#14322) * Add IsViewOrPageResult() extension (OrchardCMS#14228) * Use language keywords instead of framework type names for type references (IDE0049) (OrchardCMS#14273) * Few missing language types in .cs (OrchardCMS#14323) * Language Types in Razor files (OrchardCMS#14324) * Handle InvalidToken in UserService.ProcessValidationErrors() (OrchardCMS#14331) Co-authored-by: Mike Alhayek <[email protected]> * Make SRI hashes consistent (OrchardCMS#13775) * Update Form Migrations Create() (OrchardCMS#14272) * Fix media item icon (OrchardCMS#14342) * Update Azure.Storage.Blobs 12.18.0 (OrchardCMS#14326) * mkdocs 1.5.3 * mkdocs-material 9.3.2 * Update Jint to 3.0.0-beta-2052 (OrchardCMS#14369) * Update libphonenumber-csharp 8.13.21 (OrchardCMS#14376) * xunit 2.5.1, xunit.runner.visualstudio 2.5.1, xunit.runner.visualstudio 1.3.0 (OrchardCMS#14379) * Azure.Identity 1.10.1 (OrchardCMS#14378) * ZString 2.5.1 (OrchardCMS#14377) * mkdocs-material 9.4.0 * mkdocs-material 9.4.1 * mkdocs-material 9.4.2 * Fix Monaco doc link (OrchardCMS#14387) * Upgrade to Bootstrap 5.3.2 (OrchardCMS#14294) * Fixing Icon-Picker and cleanup sass (OrchardCMS#14393) * Set html classes to make the scripts work again (removed in OrchardCMS#9371) (OrchardCMS#14367) * Add a fallback function to crypto.randomUUID (OrchardCMS#14371) * Update HtmlSantizer 8.0.718 (OrchardCMS#14395) * Update Microsoft.Identity.Web 2.14.0 (OrchardCMS#14394) * SASS files cleanup in TheAdmin theme (OrchardCMS#14399) * Fix validation color in the login layout (OrchardCMS#14400) * Update Fluid 2.5.0 (OrchardCMS#14402) * Trim Async suffix (OrchardCMS#14407) Co-authored-by: Vincent Jacquet <[email protected]> * Typos in OrchardCore.Notifications (OrchardCMS#14409) * Update libphonenumber-csharp 8.13.22 (OrchardCMS#14408) * Fix doc typo (OrchardCMS#14411) * mkdocs-material 9.4.3 * fix: workflow module page list issue when using PostgreSQL OrchardCMS#14334 (OrchardCMS#14412) * Add @emrahtokalak as a contributor * Add @vjacquet as a contributor * Fix randomUUID, modal dialog and duplicate alerts * Add a fallback function to crypto.randomUUID (OrchardCMS#14371) * Fix modal dialog location * Remove duplicate alert in settings (OrchardCMS#14299) Co-authored-by: Hisham Bin Ateya <[email protected]> * Add OC.Notifications.Abstractions docs (OrchardCMS#14427) * Fix `Creating a modular ASP.NET Core application` tutorial (OrchardCMS#14415) Emphasize that reference must be added from the applicaiton to the module * mkdocs-material 9.4.4 * Fix form validation and link decoration (BS 5.3) (OrchardCMS#14432) * Fix admin menu background color on small screen. (OrchardCMS#14434) * Open the front page in the same browser instead of a blank tab. (OrchardCMS#14435) * Fix Publish Later Buttons (OrchardCMS#14438) * Cleanup Archive/Publish Later and remove unnecessary assets and resources (OrchardCMS#14441) * BenchmarkDotNet 0.13.9 (OrchardCMS#14436) * Update HtmlSantizer 8.0.723 (OrchardCMS#14429) * Microsoft.Identity.Web 2.15.1 (OrchardCMS#14437) * AdminBranding (OrchardCMS#14453) * Admin Navbar link (OrchardCMS#14454) * Upgrade TheTheme to use Bootstrap 5.3.2 (OrchardCMS#14451) * Fix sortable widgets (OrchardCMS#14467) * Remove "Cannot update your own roles" warning (OrchardCMS#14440) * Fix null exception in EmailTask (OrchardCMS#14471) * mkdocs-material 9.4.5 * Fix WidgetsListPart UI (OrchardCMS#14461) * Memory Leaks (OrchardCMS#14348) * Update 7.0.12 & 6.0.23 (OrchardCMS#14478) * OpenIddict 4.9.0 (OrchardCMS#14463) * Fix an exception in ListPart with header (OrchardCMS#14473) * fix: workflow module page list issue when using PostgreSQL OrchardCMS#14334 (OrchardCMS#14412) (OrchardCMS#14428) * Fix roles filter (OrchardCMS#14468) * Docs tabs * Enable tabs * Docs missing links * Docs enable footer (Previous, Next link) * Typo Release 1.8 * Docs reference links * Azure.Identity 1.10.2 (OrchardCMS#14494) * Update Taxomony field (OrchardCMS#14477) * Introduce a new Narbar shape (OrchardCMS#14488) * Can't Reload Stream Config Provider (OrchardCMS#14499) * Update YesSQL 3.4.0 (OrchardCMS#14491) * NRE in query editor (OrchardCMS#14501) * Set index length limit for MySQL (OrchardCMS#14500) Fix OrchardCMS#14338 * Fix a typo (OrchardCMS#14503) * Fix TheBlogTheme shared views (OrchardCMS#14493) * Release 1.7.1 (OrchardCMS#14474) Fix OrchardCMS#14338 --------- Co-authored-by: yaricrolletservico <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Hisham Bin Ateya <[email protected]> * Fix mysql functional tests (OrchardCMS#14502) * Release 1.7.1 (OrchardCMS#14506) Co-authored-by: Sébastien Ros <[email protected]> * Add @yaricrolletservico as a contributor * mkdocs-material 9.4.6 * Docs GraphQL: Fix url api/graphql * Fix messages class names (OrchardCMS#14508) * Update 1.7.1 release notes (OrchardCMS#14509) * js-cookie does not need to depend on jQuery (OrchardCMS#14511) * mkdocs-git-revision-date-localized-plugin 1.2.1 * NLog.Web.AspNetCore 5.3.5 * centrally define media resources (OrchardCMS#14512) * Fix TheAdmin & TheTheme for RTL languages (OrchardCMS#14486) * Fixing TheTheme newly intruduced accessibility rules and HTML rules violations (Lombiq Technologies: NEST-462) (OrchardCMS#14523) * Update libphonenumber-csharp 8.13.23 (OrchardCMS#14529) * Add @yk as a contributor * Fix MySQL index length (OrchardCMS#14513) * Release 1.7.2 (OrchardCMS#14532) * Revert " Add @yk as a contributor" This reverts commit ce82352. * Save Shell Config SubSections (OrchardCMS#14490) * Microsoft.Identity.Web 2.15.2 (OrchardCMS#14540) * SMTP should send the email if the SSL certificate is invalid (OrchardCMS#14444) Co-authored-by: Sébastien Ros <[email protected]> * Thumbnails for media app (OrchardCMS#14528) * Add a way to restart a workflow instance (OrchardCMS#14470) * pymdown-extensions 10.3.1 * Cleanup ReCaptcha services (OrchardCMS#14333) Co-authored-by: Sébastien Ros <[email protected]> * Change how ReCaptchaService consumes HttpClient (OrchardCMS#14544) * Move ContentRootPoFileLocationProvider to OC.Localization.Core.PortableObject folder (OrchardCMS#13713) * User Accounts and Custom User Settings Deployment (OrchardCMS#14208) Co-authored-by: Mike Alhayek <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Hisham Bin Ateya <[email protected]> * xunit 2.5.3 (OrchardCMS#14558) * Azure.Identity 1.10.3 (OrchardCMS#14557) * Microsoft.Identity.Web 2.15.3 (OrchardCMS#14556) * Jint 3.0.0-beta-2053 (OrchardCMS#14560) * Media caches cleanups (OrchardCMS#14087) * Add KeyVault without building a config (OrchardCMS#14550) * Dotnet 8.0 (OrchardCMS#14058) * Missing sdk (OrchardCMS#14561) * js-cookie 3.0.5 (OrchardCMS#14559) * HtmlSanitizer 8.0.746 (OrchardCMS#14577) * correct bootstrap-select dependency (OrchardCMS#14578) * Throw descriptive exception when a field is added with no type. (OrchardCMS#14569) * Add extensions for IDisplayManager (OrchardCMS#14579) * Register ReCaptchaService as singleton (OrchardCMS#14583) Co-authored-by: Sébastien Ros <[email protected]> * Assign the technical name of the field as the display name by default (OrchardCMS#14571) * Use shape when rendering Http errors to allow cusomization from the UI (OrchardCMS#14545) * Fix field wrappers CSS class names (OrchardCMS#14547) * Cleanup ReCaptchaService after changing the registration type (OrchardCMS#14587) * .NET 6.0.24, 7.0.13 (OrchardCMS#14575) * Update GetPartWrapperCssClasses and GetFieldWrapperCssClasses helpers (OrchardCMS#14591) * mkdocs-material 9.4.7 * Improve AdminDashboard Styling (OrchardCMS#14593) * Monaco 0.44.0 * remove admin.css resource dependency on audit trail list (OrchardCMS#14608) fixes OrchardCMS#14607 * Update the Admin Dashboard documentation. (OrchardCMS#14602) * Monaco js error fix (OrchardCMS#14601) * Remove admin.js dependency on fields and parts (OrchardCMS#14600) * Update libphonenumber-csharp 8.13.24 (OrchardCMS#14619) * xunit 2.6.0 (OrchardCMS#14618) * Update StackExchange.Redis 2.7.4 (OrchardCMS#14620) * Use CommitAsync() instead od Commit() (OrchardCMS#14622) * BenchmarkDotNet 0.13.10 (OrchardCMS#14623) * Add a shortcode for cache busting (OrchardCMS#14621) Co-authored-by: Zoltán Lehóczky <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Hisham Bin Ateya <[email protected]> * Invalidate cache on updating store (OrchardCMS#14612) * Improve performance for CssClass extensions (OrchardCMS#14615) * Do not show dashboard widget when `DashboardWidget` is removed. (OrchardCMS#14603) * mkdocs-material 9.4.8 * Update Jint 3.0.0-beta-2054 (OrchardCMS#14633) * Address CssClasses helper warning (OrchardCMS#14643) * Fix content preview editor resource dependency (OrchardCMS#14642) * Fix the Content-preview script (OrchardCMS#14644) * Azure.Storage.Blobs 12.19.0 (OrchardCMS#14647) * xunit 2.6.1 (OrchardCMS#14646) * Register TwoFactorAuthenticationClaimsProvider service (OrchardCMS#14651) Fix OrchardCMS#14650 * Fix monaco editor widget error * Initialize logger for YesSql to enable logging (OrchardCMS#14659) * Cleanup workflow activities (OrchardCMS#14597) * Microsoft.NET.Test.Sdk 17.8.0 (OrchardCMS#14665) * pymdown-extensions 10.4 * Minor performance update for HtmlContentBuilderExtensions (OrchardCMS#14664) * Update MailKit & MimiKit 4.3.0 (OrchardCMS#14669) * Update xUnit Analyzers 1.5.0 (OrchardCMS#14670) * Update Azure.Extensions.AspNetCore.Configuration.Secrets 1.3.0 (OrchardCMS#14672) * Update Jint 3.0.0-beta-2055 (OrchardCMS#14671) * Log a message every time Redis ConnectionMultiplexer is created * Update Azure Identity 1.10.4 (OrchardCMS#14690) * .NET 8.0.0 (OrchardCMS#14688) * Update Azure Blobs 12.19.1 (OrchardCMS#14691) * Update .NET 7.0.14 & .NET 6.0.25 (OrchardCMS#14689) * Fix missing claims for OpenID code flow. (OrchardCMS#14686) * OpenIddict 4.10.0 (OrchardCMS#14692) * Add form originated http redirect task (OrchardCMS#14610) * Set the docker image to .NET 8 (OrchardCMS#14696) * Update workflows and test runners to use .net 8 (OrchardCMS#14702) * Update YesSql to version 3.5.0 (OrchardCMS#14706) * Update Moq 4.20.69 (OrchardCMS#14705) * Drop support for .NET 6/7 (OrchardCMS#14695) * mkdocs-material 9.4.9 * Update Microsoft.SourceLink.GitHub 8.0.0 (OrchardCMS#14714) * Remove 'Async' term from a synchronous method (OrchardCMS#14710) * Missing connection dispose (OrchardCMS#14709) * Use C# 12.0 (OrchardCMS#14713) * Little cleanup (OrchardCMS#14711) * Register DataProtection_Azure asynchronously (OrchardCMS#14687) * Typos in Media (OrchardCMS#14708) * Update DocumentFormat.OpenXml 3.0.0 (OrchardCMS#14718) * mkdocs-material 9.4.10 * xUnit VS runner (OrchardCMS#14725) * Update xunit analyzers 1.6.0 (OrchardCMS#14724) * Update xunit 2.6.2 (OrchardCMS#14723) * Should not invalidate the cache of a Volatile Document. (OrchardCMS#14720) As it is never persisted and can't be retrieved from a given store, see PR comment. * Update Jint 3.0.0-beta-2056 (OrchardCMS#14729) * Fix the Github release action on Windows (OrchardCMS#14707) * Add a way to Remove User from a Role (Issue OrchardCMS#14632) (OrchardCMS#14652) --------- Co-authored-by: Mike Alhayek <[email protected]> * Update Microsoft.Identity.Web 2.15.5 (OrchardCMS#14733) * Update libphonenumber-csharp 8.13.24 (OrchardCMS#14734) * Fix Docker build (OrchardCMS#14736) * Fix docker build (OrchardCMS#14737) * Fix doc semantic error (OrchardCMS#14742) * mkdocs-material>=9.4.11 * Add Async method to ContentDefinitionManager to prevent possible thread starvation (OrchardCMS#14668) * Cleanup notifications module (OrchardCMS#14745) * Pre-render Navbar to allow resource injection (OrchardCMS#14747) * Add As/Put method to ISite to allow caching (OrchardCMS#14372) * Typo (OrchardCMS#14741) * Cleanup (OrchardCMS#14740) * Remove compiler directives (OrchardCMS#14739) * mkdocs-material 9.4.12 * Update HtmlSanitizer 8.0.795 (OrchardCMS#14753) * Update AngleSharp 1.0.6 (OrchardCMS#14673) * pymdown-extensions 10.5 * mkdocs-material 9.4.13 * Pre-render Navbar to allow resource injection (OrchardCMS#14755) * Don't throw lock timeout if shell activated (OrchardCMS#14756) * Azure DP Initializer (OrchardCMS#14750) * mkdocs-material 9.4.14 * Update Microsoft.Identity.Web 2.16.0 (OrchardCMS#14778) * Missing OC.Media dependency (OrchardCMS#14758) * Remove the double scroll in the notification item (OrchardCMS#14781) * Update libphonenumber-csharp 8.13.26 (OrchardCMS#14788) * Fix multi-targeting file locks (OrchardCMS#14732) * Fix send button style in OC.Email (OrchardCMS#14804) * Adding helpful methods for ContentPart, ContentType builders and Cont… (OrchardCMS#14717) * Add full type name for Lucene lock type In net9.0 the runtime now exposes it's own `Lock` type, dotnet/runtime#87672. This causes a build break as there is a collision between the Lucene type and the runtime type. --------- Co-authored-by: Antoine Griffard <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Sébastien Ros <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Mike Alhayek <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Hisham Bin Ateya <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: ludovic-th <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Tony Han <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Jean-Thierry Kéchichian <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Steven Spits <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: vjacquet <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Vincent Jacquet <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Szymon Seliga <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Emrah Tokalak <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Andrii Chebukin <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: yaricrolletservico <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Thomas Bolon <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: yk <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Krisztián Németh <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: lampersky <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Szabolcs Deme <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Zoltán Lehóczky <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Spyros <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Matt Varblow <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Banzai316 <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: minhtaile2712 <[email protected]>
Multiple exceptions were thrown when I started a new MySQL based instance of Orchard Core CMS. Full log is at the end of this issue. Also, this looks like a regression bug to me as a similar issue happened in the past: #4753
To Reproduce
Sorry, I don't really have a step by step instruction. All I know is that I upgraded from
1.5.0
to1.7.0
and this happens. Revert back to1.5.0
fixes the issue for me. Also, to make sure I'm not chasing phantom issue, I ran the following cmd between downgrades and upgrades:Environment
Expected behavior
Application starts successfully without any exception.
Full log
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: