fingerprint resources not working on multihost except the default site

[razonyang]

{{ range .Page.Resources.Match "sample*" }}
  {{ $img := . | fingerprint }}
  <a href="{{ $img.RelPermalink }}" target="_blank">{{ .RelPermalink }}</a>
  <img src="{{ $img.RelPermalink }}" style="width: auto; height: 200px;">
{{ end }}

[languages.en]
weight = 1

[languages.zh-hans]
weight = 2
baseURL = "https://zh-hans.example.org/"

Content strucutre

$ tree content/hello
├── index.md
├── index.zh-hans.md
├── sample.gif
└── sample.jpg

The fingerprint resources won't be published to sites folder except the default site.

$ hugo

$ ls public/en/hello  
index.html                                                                   sample.gif
sample.862081bdf97cf8ca7ff865d76807d567830c9a0fa00ebd185be19eec4f09e7a2.gif  sample.jpg
sample.e2298d882fc6cabe5eda75d0efb87f4c42b506cff19fa60aed8104d07a585013.jpg

$ ls public/zh-hans/hello              
index.html  sample.gif  sample.jpg

What version of Hugo are you using (hugo version)?

$ hugo version
hugo v0.120.3-a4892a07b41b7b3f1f143140ee4ec0a9a5cf3970+extended linux/amd64 BuildDate=2023-11-01T17:57:00Z VendorInfo=snap:0.120.3

Does this issue reproduce with the latest release?

Yes

[bep]

Looking at your example, I suspect this is for page resources only (.Resources). I would surprised if this was also broken for /assets -- as that is a very common pattern (fingerprinting CSS files).

[bep]

I'm in the finishing section of rewriting/improving how we do the above, so I have put this on the #11549 list of things I will check.

[razonyang]

Looking at your example, I suspect this is for page resources only (.Resources).

You're right, I used fingerprint for my styles and JS as well, both of them works as expected.

[bep]

A quick note; there's certainly a bug here, but even for multihost setups there will be resources that's shared between languages (which gets even more true in next Hugo where we stop duplication of bundled resources), which means that:

• .RelPermalink will always work and point to a file that's below each host root.
• .Permalink will for these shared resources point below the language's host baseURL.

[razonyang]

.RelPermalink will always work and point to a file that's below each host root.

Hi, not sure I understand this correctlly, is that mean I'm able to generate resources for each host?

There is one reason I don't want share resources between multihost is that the Cloudflare CDN is very slow in my location (China), I want to split the content into multihost:

1. example.org for English site which served by Cloudflare Pages and CDN.
2. zh-hans.example.org for Chinese site which served by source server located Asia.

[github-actions]

This issue has been automatically locked since there has not been any recent activity after it was closed. Please open a new issue for related bugs.