-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 308
add a field for funding goal #110
Comments
My only concern with this is that it provides a mental reason to not do something. "Oh, it's only 5 days left...he'll never get there" I know I've done that with kickstarter. It turns out less about doing the original goal, pay towards a good thing, and instead about "am I committing to something success/failure bound." |
@mitechie So what would that look like in this context? I guess, "Oh, he's only 5% towards his personal funding goal. Must be a schmuck." Two thoughts:
Kickstarter depends on urgency. Gittip is about the slow build-up. Seems like we should be able to implement funding goals in a way that supports that. |
Bah, nevermind. I misread that you were attempting to build some of the urgency to match kickstarter. I was speaking directly to the case of "Oh this is cool, but it's only 20% funded with 2 days left...I'll pass" that I've experienced on kickstarter. You're right, in gittip's case, it would be different since it's more of a "I'd like to get to xx/wk" and there's not the feeling of helping a lost cause that you can find in kickstarter. |
Well, maybe I was thinking at first of trying to capture a sense of urgency, but I like the slow build-up much better. Good feedback. |
Now we have credit and debit columns inside gittip. I think this is more standard and normal and clearer.
Sorry, those last three belong on #43. |
Deployed. |
This comment from @therabidbanana (see #98) got me thinking:
One of the things that makes Kickstarter work is the clear funding goal: $3,000 in 30 days.
How about a facility on Gittip for stating a funding goal?
"My personal funding goal is to {give,receive} ________ per week."
Since gifts are ongoing for ever we don't get the
niceurgency of Kickstarter, "only 10 days left!" It'd be more about a slow build over time. But it does give some sense of movement and accomplishment. I actually like the way Gittip feels like a train building up momentum. Since gifts are recurring, if Gittip stopped growing entirely we would still be moving $110 every week for quite a while. It's like we're ratcheting it up or something.This could help satisfy @jacobian and @toastdriven's desire to give money but not receive any (see #61). Depending on how we implement it we could even preclude gifts to people who have explicitly set a funding goal of receiving zero dollars.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: