Daemon cli not working as expected

[odesenfans]

Hello,

I'm trying to install the latest version of the daemon to try it out, but I'm a bit perplexed by the install procedure. Could you add documentation to show how to start the daemon, and/or release the new version on npm?

[achingbrain]

Please see the changes in #91 - do these make it a bit clearer?

[odesenfans]

Hello @achingbrain, thanks for the update! I managed to install the latest version. However, the daemon does not seem to work.

npm i -g @libp2p/[email protected]
jsp2pd --help
# Returns to the prompt and prints nothing
jsp2pd
# Returns to the prompt as well

I'm trying this on a pretty standard install of Ubuntu 20.04 and nodejs v17.9.0.

PS: I did uninstall the previous version of the daemon, and running the daemon with DEBUG=* does not yield additional information.

[odesenfans]

I looked into it a bit more, I guess these lines explain why the daemon does not start.

export async function createLibp2pServer(listenAddr, argv) {
    // const libp2p = await createLibp2p(argv)
    // const daemon = await createServer(new Multiaddr(argv.listen), libp2p)
    throw new Error('Not implemented yet');
}

[odesenfans]

@wemeetagain this issue is not resolved, see my comments above. The doc explains how to install the daemon correctly, but the daemon does not work as expected once installed.

[achingbrain]

It was closed automatically by the linked PR

[achingbrain]

Good spot on the commented out code - the modules published by this mono-repo are only really used in testing interop between js-libp2p and go-libp2p - in those tests it's started programatically using the @libp2p/daemon-server module rather than via the command line @libp2p/daemon module.

Would you like to open a PR that fixes the CLI tool up for use outside of the libp2p interop suite?

It should be relatively straight forward - the createLibp2p function is exported by libp2p, you just need to figure out a way to convert argv to the options object that function expects, and createServer is exported by @libp2p/daemon-server.

[odesenfans]

I can give it a try over the weekend, sure!

[p-shahi]

@odesenfans Any update :) Are you still interested in doing this?

[odesenfans]

Hello, in the end I switched to writing my own network daemon with rust-libp2p.

[achingbrain]

That's interesting, is it available anywhere? I'd love to try to adapt it to run interop tests against in the same way we use this module and go-libp2p-daemon in js-libp2p.

[odesenfans]

Hi @achingbrain, you can find it here: https://github.com/aleph-im/p2p-service. The goal was not to be compatible with the protobuf protocol you defined for the daemon, so you won't be able to use it as a stand-in replacement. We have several services in our system that are interested in subscribing to pubsub topics, so I went for a RabbitMQ interface for pubsub and a small HTTP server for stuff like dialing peers.

It's pretty basic at the moment but it does the job so far.