Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Open Source Design blog on Medium (Join the Medium publication here!) #17

Closed
razetime opened this issue Nov 20, 2015 · 61 comments
Closed

Comments

@razetime
Copy link
Contributor

I have created a Medium publication for Open source, design, which could help our organization reach more people, and contribute more to the design community.
It lives at https://medium.com/open-source-design, and I think we can put all our posts in the http://opensourcedesign.net/articles/ page into this medium page.
Anyone interested in publishing, or have any ideas?

@plastelina
Copy link
Member

great one! 👍

my account: https://medium.com/@karolinaferenz (if you want to follow me) , I've got several publications in draft...waiting for my laptop to come back form repair and will be ready to publish :).

@simonv3
Copy link
Member

simonv3 commented Nov 20, 2015

I'm very curious about how some other people on here feel about Medium, considering it is not very Open Sourcey at all, I think Medium would even own the articles?

I'm all for writing articles and publishing them on our own feed and then copying them to medium. But I think we should try to make sure we at least have our own copies of everything.

@plastelina
Copy link
Member

I think medium is one of the best ways to reach out to designers, I met epic people there! Fantastic UX/UI, interaction and web designers as well as developers. In my opinion, looking at this subject - that open source should only use open source make it CLOSE SOURCE, because you dont have an option to actually chat to people and TELL them that there is an OPEN SOURCE community for designer...I only found out 2 years ago open source and it was by an accident.

Also...why everything have to be discussed to the level of insanity?
If you dont like medium - don't use it, find alternative and share it here! Simples.
If you like it - use it.

Yes, I used to use gimp and few other programs but that was over 15 years ago and these were just beginning of what is happening now. Now open source design tools are epic and they need more shout out - medium is great for that.

@elioqoshi
Copy link
Member

Medium supports Creative Commons, so that's enough reason for me to support them (apart their new ugly logo honestly)

@simonv3
Copy link
Member

simonv3 commented Nov 20, 2015

@plastelina Open Source is a Very Opinionated Community. The divergent opinions about what open software means is what attracts people to it. Debate and conversation about how to best make software free is a critical part of the conversation. Telling people to not have that conversation is not productive because it will happen. Open Source, like everything in life, is a series of compromises. When you're talking to people working in Open Source, this conversation is going to happen - if I hadn't brought it up, someone else would have.

And like I said - I'm for doing this, as long as we make sure that anything written under the Open Source Design banner also has a home on our own site. There's a variety of reasons for this, and Medium being or not being Open Source is just one of them. Medium is a venture backed company that - as far as I'm aware - doesn't make any money yet. What if, like Rdio, it shuts down next week? Or, like Twitter, is starting to have to lay off its employees because it doesn't make enough money? Both Twitter and Rdio are fantastic products and have changed things for a lot of people. Medium is like that too. But even if it supports CC like @elioqoshi mentions, I think owning the things written under the OSD makes a lot of sense.

@elioqoshi do you have a link for the support of creative commons?

@simonv3
Copy link
Member

simonv3 commented Nov 20, 2015

Also, please, if not being able to write on Medium is what's been preventing people writing about Open Source Design, please start writing on Medium. If you tell me you wrote it, I'll gladly copy it over to the articles myself.

@elioqoshi
Copy link
Member

@simonv3 here:
http://creativecommons.org/weblog/entry/45495

@simonv3
Copy link
Member

simonv3 commented Nov 20, 2015

@elioqoshi That's awesome, thanks!

@rdbartlett
Copy link
Contributor

I wrote a post to share my design process. I use a lot of proprietary software to make open source software, heh.

I'm happy to copy it over to Medium to get this publication started if y'all think it fits.

@jancborchardt
Copy link
Member

We could crosspost yeah, but the original posts should always be on opensourcedesign.net. These pages are tools to reach more people, but for actual writing and publishing there’s great open source platforms already like Ghost.

@simonv3
Copy link
Member

simonv3 commented Nov 20, 2015

qb on IRC just pointed me to the fact that you can easily import things to Medium here: https://medium.com/p/import

@simonv3
Copy link
Member

simonv3 commented Nov 20, 2015

@rdbartlett I think that'd be cool! Though, in the spirit of Medium being about written things (is it?) do you have a transcript version of the talk? I'm not sure what the general consensus is on posting videos on Medium?

@rdbartlett
Copy link
Contributor

@simonv3 it's mostly me demonstrating how I use my particular combination of tools, so it doesn't translate too well into text.

@rdbartlett
Copy link
Contributor

@razetime I'm wondering if, rather than just porting my story across to Medium, I reframe it into a sort of introductory blog post? Like, hi I'm Rich, this is why I care about open source design, here's some talks and articles and projects I've had a hand in...

@rdbartlett
Copy link
Contributor

I'm imagining that lots of people in this community could do a similar thing. Something more engaging, sharable, and narrative-based than the brief bios we already have.

@simonv3
Copy link
Member

simonv3 commented Nov 20, 2015

That would be pretty cool. We could potentially stagger the posts as well - just for continuous returns? We can also create a special layout on our website for this kind of story "profiles" or something.

@razetime @rdbartlett @plastelina @elioqoshi would you all be interested in spearheading some sort of initiative like this? Maybe create a list of questions that people should try to answer? Provide some example posts?

@simonv3
Copy link
Member

simonv3 commented Nov 20, 2015

(Also @razetime if you could share some publishing rights to anyone who's interested in maintaining this that would be grand).

@rdbartlett
Copy link
Contributor

@plastelina I'd love to read about how you accidentally discovered open source 💃

@rdbartlett
Copy link
Contributor

So instead of doing that, I just wrote a totally new post. Very keen to hear feedback :)

https://medium.com/@richdecibels/open-source-design-just-steal-everything-5c44ca793721#.z2is2ra8r

@razetime do you want to add me as an editor on that publication?

@elioqoshi
Copy link
Member

@simonv3 Yes, I'd love to!

@razetime
Copy link
Contributor Author

Sorry that I did not respond, but I was sleeping at the time at the replies
came in.
I'll make sure that everybody who is interested, is added.
Any more thoughts?

On Sat, Nov 21, 2015 at 1:36 PM, Elio Qoshi [email protected]
wrote:

@simonv3 https://github.com/simonv3 Yes, I'd love to!


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub
#17 (comment)
.

@razetime
Copy link
Contributor Author

Everyone who is interested can join, as a writer. If you write better posts, you will become an editor. @plastelina @rdbartlett You're in.

@razetime
Copy link
Contributor Author

And @simonv3 I'd like to take an initiative like this.
We can write about how we discovered open source, and (possibly) design.
Everybody who wants to publish, just keep one thing in mind: Write about Open Source Design.

@plastelina
Copy link
Member

@simonv3 thank you for clarifying the issue for me :D. You are missing the point, every community is strongly opinionated. What I was trying to point out is that you, pretty much always diss a lot of initiatives to push open source design to the open world. I'm not trying to dismiss what Open Source sand for, I'm trying to come up with an ideas to spread the word and as you mentioned yourself - it will attract specific people, not every designer / developer will join. It's a basic PR ( as in public relations not push repository ;))move. /end of rant ;).

Also, there was no debate about opening twitter account and there is an issue about opening a medium account!? C'mon, medium is actually one of those rare tool that attracts designers and yes, it might be shut down at some point in the future, but why not use its capacity to spread the word and educate people what open source is. There are a lot of open source contributors to medium already.

I'm writing articles on Medium as myself, but I'm happy to contribute to Open Source Design Medium account. ARGH! need my computer back, feeling like I've lost a arm...

@razetime
Copy link
Contributor Author

@plastelina no need to hurry, let's be slow and steady. And plus, Medium IS
making money, with native advertising in posts, but I still think that is not
enough. So let's keep an original with ourselves, and put a copy of our
articles on Medium.

IF you allow, @SimonV, we can keep some of the articles exclusive to medium,
though.

@simonv3
Copy link
Member

simonv3 commented Nov 21, 2015

@razetime This isn't about me allowing it or not, this is about building a community consensus on whether we should move forward with something.

@plastelina it sounds like we should hash things out in some form of private conversation - I never meant to make it sound like I'm dissing ideas - in fact, I feel like I've been supportive of most of the initiatives proposed, just cautious about most of the ones that aren't open source. Please feel free to DM me on IRC or on Twitter if you want to continue this conversation without clogging up everyone's notifications / emails.

Communal Decision Making

We're not Anonymous (rag tag bunch of people with only the loosest affiliation), and I don't think we should be. I think it's important that every one in the community gets an opportunity to voice concerns, and that the Open Source Design community needs to at least have some form of consensus on what it stands for. This is exactly why I think we need some more structure - I've raised issues on bylaws, codes of conducts, how to reach consensus before. Please please please give your input on those issues. If the majority of people in this group feel that we should use closed source tools like Slack and Medium because they'll achieve those goals better, then maybe we should. But if that majority of people is silent and doesn't speak up about these things, how are the people doing things meant to know that?

(This is why I thought it was a good idea to put the logo thing up to a vote, it allows quiet people to give their opinion without having to get into this conversation)

I have no idea who controls the Twitter account. We should have probably had a public conversation about that too.

@simonv3
Copy link
Member

simonv3 commented Nov 21, 2015

@rdbartlett I like that post! @razetime thanks for assigning people editors. We should possibly link the posts to Twitter as well?

@raucao
Copy link
Member

raucao commented Nov 21, 2015

IF you allow, @SimonV, we can keep some of the articles exclusive to medium, though.

Why would you keep something exclusive to Medium, when it's easy not to?

@GarthDB
Copy link
Member

GarthDB commented Nov 21, 2015

I've been publishing articles to both opendesign.foundation and Medium. It works out well us, but we go where the designers are and don't really have the requirement of only using open source projects.

@simonv3
Copy link
Member

simonv3 commented Nov 21, 2015

And maybe we do want to be more like Anonymous (everyone does what they
think is best), and let the Open Design Foundation be the structured entity?
On Nov 21, 2015 10:45 AM, "Garth Braithwaite" [email protected]
wrote:

I've been publishing articles to both opendesign.foundation and Medium
https://medium.com/design-open. It works out well us, but we go where
the designers are and don't really have the requirement of only using open
source projects.


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub
#17 (comment)
.

@raucao
Copy link
Member

raucao commented Nov 23, 2015

Ghost offers hosting and is itself a design-focussed open source project. I'm sure they'd gladly host OSD for free if you ask them.

@GarthDB
Copy link
Member

GarthDB commented Nov 23, 2015

If you can get free hosting that would be awesome.

@simonv3
Copy link
Member

simonv3 commented Nov 23, 2015

@skddc @GarthDB I just pointed out that we could potentially also reach out to the Sandstorm people for hosting, and then we can host all sorts of things on their grains as well -> #19.

@bnvk and @jancborchardt asked in opensourcedesign/opensourcedesign.github.io#33 whether we should post on the OSD website first before posting to Medium - or at least saying on Medium This post was original published on OSD (or some such).

simonv3 added a commit that referenced this issue Nov 23, 2015
In the spirit of keeping track of who controls what and as raised in #18 and #17.
@GarthDB
Copy link
Member

GarthDB commented Nov 23, 2015

Hey - Wordpress.com is opensource now too, just to muddy the waters further.

@jancborchardt
Copy link
Member

@GarthDB »now« – you’re kidding, right? ;) Wordpress has been open source since forever.

@GarthDB
Copy link
Member

GarthDB commented Nov 23, 2015

@jancborchardt Wordpress, yes. Wordpress.com, no, until now.

@aoloe
Copy link

aoloe commented Nov 23, 2015

hey guys, this is a ticket about putting something on medium, not a way to chit chat...
really, you urgently need to get to an agreement on which chat platform you want to use and stop filling up everybody's inbox / github dashboard!
(and i'd prefer not to unsubscribe the repositories... but i will have to if i keep on getting 200+ pings a day from you!)

@jancborchardt
Copy link
Member

@aoloe you can unsubscribe from individual issues – right sidebar, »unsubscribe« button. Sorry though for getting off the rails.

@aoloe
Copy link

aoloe commented Nov 23, 2015

@jancborchardt it's a general problem for opensourcedesign lately.
please count the number of "chatty" replies to this topic and put the number in here.
if it's painful to count, it's because you're doing it wrong.

@GarthDB
Copy link
Member

GarthDB commented Nov 23, 2015

@aoloe There's not really a right or a wrong way to have an open discussion; you may not like how it happens, but that doesn't make it wrong.

@simonv3
Copy link
Member

simonv3 commented Nov 23, 2015

@jancborchardt I think @GarthDB meant more specifically that wordpress.com is open source (the hosting platform), as opposed to just the wordpress blog publishing platform.

Hey @aoloe - you could suggest changing how we discuss things in the bylaws conversation, or create a new issue for this specifically. I actually don't think there's too much chit-chat going on in this thread (opensourcedesign/opensourcedesign.github.io#16 is a different issue). I also heartily recommend creating a filter for GitHub emails (you can even specify opensourcedesign directly).

Edit: in case anyone didn't know, there's also the IRC channel for #opensourcedesign - you can access it at http://chat.opensourcedesign.net

@aoloe
Copy link

aoloe commented Nov 23, 2015

@simonv3 and @GarthDB , there's not right way, no.
but there are better and worse tools for running a specific conversation.
i'm just a visitor in this community and i won't tell you, how you should run a conversation.
i can only tell you that there are many signs that show that this conversation does not run through the right medium.
that was my last message in this topic. and i will unsubscribe now, eventually missing posts that indeed are about the best way to manage the side publishing on medium.

@raucao
Copy link
Member

raucao commented Nov 24, 2015

Just in time: http://ma.tt/2015/11/dance-to-calypso/ ;)

@simonv3 simonv3 mentioned this issue Nov 25, 2015
3 tasks
@raucao
Copy link
Member

raucao commented Nov 25, 2015

By the way, that only works with WordPress.com at the moment, because WP Stable doesn't have the API yet.

https://desktop.wordpress.com/

@razetime razetime changed the title Open Source Design on Medium Open Source Design blog on Medium (Join the Medium publication here!) Apr 1, 2016
bnvk pushed a commit that referenced this issue Nov 3, 2016
In the spirit of keeping track of who controls what and as raised in #18 and #17.
bnvk pushed a commit that referenced this issue Nov 3, 2016
In the spirit of keeping track of who controls what and as raised in #18 and #17.
@jancborchardt
Copy link
Member

So ever since we opened the account, there is no single post on it: https://medium.com/open-source-design

As said in opensourcedesign/opensourcedesign.github.io#27 (comment):

As for the Medium account we also have floating around which was set up by @razetime, I would say we get rid of it since it has no articles, and to promote our own articles page and as we already support a lot of proprietary platforms. What do you think?

@elioqoshi
Copy link
Member

Was not aware we had a Medium account. I suggest we get rid of it as the irony of using another proprietary platform is too overwhelming here.

@jancborchardt
Copy link
Member

I mailed @razetime about removing this Medium account and the Facebook account (opensourcedesign/opensourcedesign.github.io#27) :)

@jancborchardt
Copy link
Member

jancborchardt commented Apr 22, 2017

Closing this just like the Facebook page issue. We should remove this Medium account too @razetime @plastelina @rdbartlett

See also #86 update of our community platform list.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

10 participants