Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on Sep 24, 2022. It is now read-only.

Avoid acronyms #67

Closed
camerons opened this issue Dec 1, 2019 · 12 comments
Closed

Avoid acronyms #67

camerons opened this issue Dec 1, 2019 · 12 comments
Labels
good first issue If you're new to the project and want to help start with issues tagged with this label. improve For any suggestions about how to make templates better. writing-tips

Comments

@camerons
Copy link
Member

camerons commented Dec 1, 2019

Doc: https://github.com/thegooddocsproject/templates/blob/master/writing-tips.md

Re:

Avoid colloquialisms and jargon because it makes it harder for a non-native English speaker to understand your words.

Hannah McKenzie
13:36 14 Nov
Perhaps worth mentioning to avoid acronyms too?

@camerons camerons added good first issue If you're new to the project and want to help start with issues tagged with this label. improve For any suggestions about how to make templates better. writing-tips labels Dec 1, 2019
@naomis-github
Copy link

Should we also add that spelling should be consistent throughout the doc (e.g. words with hyphens should always be hyphenated every time it is used)?

@camerons
Copy link
Member Author

camerons commented Mar 2, 2020

Yes @naomis-github, that is a good suggestion. We have decided to align ourselves with the the Google developer documentation style guide, https://developers.google.com/style .
Also, I'm aware that a number of our writers (myself included) sometimes use the free version of https://www.grammarly.com/.
One thing that would be valuable would be to determine whether grammarly aligns with the Google Style Guide.
And then to do an audit against the style guide and fix issues that you find.

@jaredmorgs
Copy link
Contributor

I'm trying to find citations about what style guides Grammarly adopts but they appear to be pretty tight-lipped about it.

errara-ai offer a linter called Vale that lets you select from various style guides like Google, Microsoft but it is non trivial to set up.

@jaredmorgs
Copy link
Contributor

https://developers.google.com/style/abbreviations has how to deal with that covered

@naomis-github
Copy link

I just had a look at grammarly; indeed, it doesn't look like they have an openly available writing guideline. They offer writing style settings (i.e. academic, business, technical, casual, creative) if that helps.

@camerons
Copy link
Member Author

An editor of one of my articles has recently pointed me to https://languagetool.org/ which is an open source equivalent to grammarly, sponsored by the European Union, which we could either decide to use as is, or configure to work with the style guide we choose (currently the Google Developers Style Guide).

@bjnath
Copy link

bjnath commented Apr 20, 2020

Given the nascent state of automated Natural Language Understanding, I hesitate to put any program in a position of final authority. We can take its counsel, just as we take it from colleagues, but the ultimate decision belongs in human hands.

I'll go further and say it belongs in a single pair of human hands. We decide whose hands and record every decision for consistency going forward.

@bjnath
Copy link

bjnath commented Apr 20, 2020

To be clear, I'm all for using a style guide, particularly Google's since it's purpose-built. But inevitably issues fall through the cracks, and these should head straight to the hands of the Supreme Final Human Arbiter.

@shreyas1599
Copy link
Contributor

shreyas1599 commented May 15, 2020

@jaredmorgs @camerons I'm trying to open a PR for this. How does the following sound?

Avoid using acronyms. Use the spelt-out form of an acronym followed by the acronym in parentheses if it is absolutely necessary. Do this for the first mention. For every subsequent reference, use the acronym itself.

Or should I ignore the last two sentences?

Avoid using acronyms. Use the spelt-out form of an acronym followed by the acronym in parentheses if it is absolutely necessary.

And for the second part, changing this:

Use consistent language and tone throughout your docs.

to:

Use consistent language, spelling and tone throughout your docs.

@jaredmorgs
Copy link
Contributor

I don't think that using acronyms or initialisms is "bad," as this text is suggesting. It is more a case of "use with care."

I remember listening to an episode of Grammar Girl podcast that suggested that if you were going to use the acronym or initialism more than five times in a document, then you take the time to abbreviate it first then use it throughout the document.

So maybe something like (don't think you need to take this suggestion verbatim):

Do not include acronyms or initialisms in your documentation without writing the spelled-out form on the first use. You can use the acronym or initialism for subsequent references.

@jaredmorgs
Copy link
Contributor

Use consistent language, spelling, and tone throughout your docs.

I think this one is good (note the added oxford comma).

@emckean
Copy link
Contributor

emckean commented May 19, 2020

fixed in PR #125

Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Labels
good first issue If you're new to the project and want to help start with issues tagged with this label. improve For any suggestions about how to make templates better. writing-tips
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

6 participants